What is Discrete Trial Training (DTT)?
Discrete Trial Training (DTT) is a structured teaching method primarily used in Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) therapy to help children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and other developmental disabilities learn new skills. This evidence-based approach breaks down complex skills into smaller, manageable components and teaches them systematically through repeated practice and reinforcement.
DTT was first developed by Dr. Ivar Lovaas in the 1960s and has since become one of the most widely researched and implemented interventions for autism. Research shows that intensive DTT programs can lead to significant improvements in IQ, language development, and adaptive behaviors in children with autism.
The Core Components of Discrete Trial Training
1. Discriminative Stimulus (SD)
The discriminative stimulus is the instruction or cue that signals the child to perform a specific behavior. This could be a verbal instruction like “Touch red” or a visual cue such as holding up a red card.
2. Response
The response is the child’s behavior following the discriminative stimulus. This can be verbal (saying a word), motor (pointing to an object), or any other measurable behavior.
3. Consequence
The consequence follows the child’s response and can be either reinforcement (for correct responses) or correction (for incorrect responses). Positive reinforcement is crucial for maintaining motivation and encouraging learning.
4. Inter-Trial Interval (ITI)
The inter-trial interval is the brief pause between trials, typically lasting 3-5 seconds. This allows the child to process the information and prepare for the next trial.
Why DTT is Effective: The Research Behind the Method
According to a comprehensive meta-analysis published in the Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, DTT interventions show significant positive effects across multiple skill domains. Specifically:
- Language Development: Children receiving DTT show an average improvement of 1.2 standard deviations in expressive language skills
- Cognitive Abilities: IQ gains of 15-25 points have been documented in intensive DTT programs
- Social Skills: 78% of children show measurable improvements in social interaction skills after 6 months of DTT
- Adaptive Behaviors: Daily living skills improve by an average of 40% within the first year of implementation
The National Professional Development Center on Autism Spectrum Disorder recognizes DTT as an evidence-based practice, citing over 25 high-quality research studies supporting its effectiveness.
Step-by-Step DTT Implementation Guide
Phase 1: Assessment and Goal Setting
Step 1: Conduct Initial Assessment Before beginning DTT, conduct a comprehensive assessment to identify the child’s current skill levels, learning preferences, and areas of need. Use standardized assessment tools such as the Verbal Behavior Milestones Assessment and Placement Program (VB-MAPP) or the Assessment of Basic Language and Learning Skills (ABLLS-R).
Step 2: Develop Specific Learning Objectives Create measurable, observable goals based on the assessment results. For example:
- “Child will receptively identify 10 common objects with 80% accuracy across 3 consecutive sessions”
- “Child will imitate 5 gross motor actions with 90% accuracy”
Phase 2: Setting Up the Learning Environment
Step 3: Prepare Materials Gather all necessary materials before beginning the session. This includes:
- Visual aids and teaching materials
- Data collection sheets
- Reinforcers (preferred items or activities)
- Timer for inter-trial intervals
Step 4: Minimize Distractions Create a distraction-free environment by:
- Removing unnecessary items from the table
- Ensuring good lighting
- Positioning chairs appropriately for easy interaction
Phase 3: Conducting DTT Sessions
Step 5: Present the Discriminative Stimulus Present the instruction clearly and consistently. Use the same wording each time to avoid confusion. For example, if teaching color identification, always say “Touch blue” rather than varying between “Touch blue,” “Find blue,” or “Show me blue.”
Step 6: Prompt if Necessary If the child doesn’t respond within 3-5 seconds, provide a prompt. Use the least intrusive prompt necessary:
- Verbal prompt: “Touch the blue one”
- Gestural prompt: Point to the correct item
- Physical prompt: Guide the child’s hand to the correct response
Step 7: Provide Immediate Consequence
- Correct Response: Provide enthusiastic praise and preferred reinforcer immediately
- Incorrect Response: Say “Try again” or “No” in a neutral tone, then provide the correct answer
Step 8: Record Data Document each trial’s outcome immediately to track progress accurately.
Detailed DTT Examples by Skill Domain
Example 1: Receptive Identification (Colors)
Target Skill: Child will receptively identify primary colors
Materials: Red, blue, and yellow cards
Trial Sequence:
- SD: Therapist places three colored cards in front of child and says “Touch red”
- Response: Child touches the red card
- Consequence: “Great job! You touched red!” + preferred reinforcer
- ITI: 3-second pause
- Next Trial: “Touch blue”
Data Collection: Record “+” for correct, “-” for incorrect, “P” for prompted
Progression: Start with 2 colors, add third color when child achieves 80% accuracy
Example 2: Expressive Labeling (Body Parts)
Target Skill: Child will expressively label body parts
Materials: None required
Trial Sequence:
- SD: Therapist points to their own nose and asks “What’s this?”
- Response: Child says “nose”
- Consequence: “Excellent! That’s your nose!” + high-five
- ITI: 4-second pause
- Next Trial: Point to ear, “What’s this?”
Prompting Hierarchy:
- Full verbal prompt: “Nose”
- Partial verbal prompt: “N…”
- No prompt
Example 3: Imitation (Motor Actions)
Target Skill: Child will imitate gross motor actions
Materials: None required
Trial Sequence:
- SD: Therapist says “Do this” while clapping hands
- Response: Child claps hands
- Consequence: “Nice clapping!” + preferred toy for 10 seconds
- ITI: 5-second pause
- Next Trial: “Do this” while touching head
Teaching Tips:
- Start with simple, one-step actions
- Use exaggerated movements
- Ensure child is paying attention before presenting SD
Advanced DTT Strategies and Troubleshooting
Managing Challenging Behaviors
Problem: Child frequently engages in escape behaviors Solution:
- Reduce session length
- Increase reinforcer quality
- Incorporate movement breaks
- Check task difficulty level
Problem: Child shows prompt dependency Solution:
- Implement systematic prompt fading
- Use time delay procedures
- Vary prompt types
- Ensure reinforcement is contingent on independent responses
Data-Driven Decision Making
Successful DTT implementation requires continuous data analysis. Track the following metrics:
- Acquisition Rate: Number of trials to reach mastery criterion
- Maintenance: Retention of skills over time
- Generalization: Use of skills across different settings and people
- Response Latency: Time between SD and response
Generalization Strategies
To ensure skills transfer beyond the therapy setting:
- Vary Teaching Examples: Use multiple exemplars of the same concept
- Change Instructors: Have different people present the same trials
- Modify Settings: Practice skills in various environments
- Natural Environment Training: Incorporate learning opportunities into daily routines
Common Mistakes to Avoid in DTT
1. Inconsistent Presentation
Varying the discriminative stimulus can confuse the learner. Maintain consistency in wording, tone, and presentation style.
2. Delayed Reinforcement
Reinforcement must be immediate to be effective. Any delay reduces the association between the correct response and the positive consequence.
3. Over-Prompting
Providing prompts too quickly prevents independent learning. Allow sufficient response time before prompting.
4. Inadequate Data Collection
Accurate data is essential for monitoring progress and making informed decisions about program modifications.
5. Ignoring Motivation
Failing to assess and update reinforcer preferences can lead to decreased motivation and slower learning.
Measuring Success: DTT Outcomes and Progress Monitoring
Key Performance Indicators
Accuracy: Percentage of correct responses across trials
- Acquisition Phase: 50-79% accuracy
- Mastery Phase: 80% or higher across 3 consecutive sessions
Response Latency: Time between instruction and response
- Target: 3 seconds or less for mastered skills
Retention: Maintenance of skills over time
- Conduct probe sessions weekly to assess retention
Long-Term Outcomes
Research demonstrates significant long-term benefits of intensive DTT programs:
- Educational Placement: 47% of children receiving intensive DTT are placed in mainstream classrooms compared to 2% of controls
- Language Development: Average vocabulary increases from 50 words to over 1,000 words within two years
- Independence: 60% of children show significant improvements in daily living skills
Technology Integration in Modern DTT
Digital Data Collection
Modern DTT programs increasingly utilize tablet-based applications for:
- Real-time data entry
- Automated progress graphs
- Immediate feedback to therapists
- Parent portal access for home data
Virtual Reality Applications
Emerging research shows promise for VR-enhanced DTT, particularly for:
- Social skills training
- Safety skill instruction
- Generalization to community settings
Cost-Effectiveness and Insurance Considerations
DTT programs typically require 20-40 hours per week of intensive intervention. While the initial cost is significant, research indicates:
- Return on Investment: Every dollar spent on early intensive intervention saves $3-5 in special education costs
- Insurance Coverage: Most states now mandate autism therapy coverage, including DTT
- Medicaid Coverage: Available in all 50 states for qualified families
Future Directions and Emerging Trends
Precision Teaching Integration
Combining DTT with precision teaching methods shows promise for:
- Faster skill acquisition
- Better retention rates
- More efficient use of therapy time
Parent-Implemented DTT
Training parents to implement DTT procedures:
- Increases practice opportunities
- Improves generalization
- Reduces overall program costs
- Enhances family involvement
Conclusion
Discrete Trial Training remains one of the most effective, evidence-based interventions for children with autism spectrum disorder. When implemented correctly with proper planning, consistent execution, and continuous data monitoring, DTT can produce significant improvements in language, cognitive, social, and adaptive skills.
The key to successful DTT implementation lies in:
- Thorough initial assessment
- Clear, measurable objectives
- Consistent trial presentation
- Immediate reinforcement
- Systematic data collection
- Regular program modifications based on data
As the field continues to evolve, integrating technology and expanding to parent-implemented models will likely increase DTT’s accessibility and effectiveness. For families and professionals considering DTT, the extensive research base provides confidence in its potential to create meaningful, lasting improvements in children’s lives.
Remember that DTT is most effective when part of a comprehensive treatment plan that may include other ABA techniques, speech therapy, occupational therapy, and educational interventions. Consultation with qualified professionals is essential for developing and implementing an effective DTT program tailored to each child’s unique needs.
References
- National Professional Development Center on Autism Spectrum Disorder – Evidence-Based Practices
- Autism Speaks – Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA)
- Association for Behavior Analysis International – Practice Guidelines
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention – Autism Spectrum Disorder Treatment
- Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis – Discrete Trial Training Research